Summer Fruit Pot Pie: New Duds for an Old Fruit Pie Friend

Rustic Bread Salad
Rustic Tuscan Panzanella Bread Salad: Best-Ever Bread Salad with Peak of the Season Tomatoes
August 27, 2016
Mason Jars Filled with Pickled Shrimp
Setting Sail with Pickled Shrimp: Getting Pot-Lucky, Nautical Edition
September 3, 2016

Perfect Peaches Ready for a Summer Fruit Pie

I can see the problem you are having.  A giant mound of peach perfection and you are so tired of fruit pie and cobbler (Okay, we should probably admit that is NOT really a thing, being tired of pie and cobbler).   But it’s a holiday weekend and you MUST use that beautiful bounty ASAP yet you would rather be on the beach, boat, SUP or _____(fill in the blank). So with that last hurrah of summer celebration hurtling toward you at ram speed, here’s a dessert that you can make in a flash, yet will look like you have been slaving away.  Stone fruit –still abundantly available – is the perfect choice for this “cobbler, not-a-cobbler.”  Cut into wedges, a peach or nectarine is sizable enough to hold its shape (ain’t nobody likin’ fruit mush) and comes with its own good dose of pectin.  I throw in a few blueberries for a wee bit of flavor, color, and texture contrast, but warn against fruit with a high water content and thin skins (I got my eyes on you raspberries and blackberries.)

Normally a fruit cobbler comes with a streusel or pastry crumb topping, but I love this idea of biscuits.  I would say it’s fresh and new, but since I created this dish at New World Grill some 20 years ago, I will settle on timeless. It’s hard to find a fruit pot pie at all, and the ones I have seen are made with a double pastry crust.  This dish has no bottom – which means…..???? You got it!! No soggy bottoms!!! Pastry fraidies unite! You can do this!!  Just cook the fruit with a little cornstarch stove-top then drop biscuit dough on top. Super easy to serve as well because everyone gets a heaping spoon of fruit topped with a biscuit topped with …Ice Cream? Whip Cream? Greek Yogurt? Yes. Yes. And Yes. Please. It’s dessert magic.

Summer Fruit Pot Pie

I have made this with peaches and nectarines (peel the peaches, but no need on the nectarines), but you might also try plums or apricots.  And cherries could be a nice alternative to the blueberries I use.  Just keep a sturdy skin in mind when improvising.  And always let a fruit dessert cool to avoid the juice-bomb.  This is best served same-day, an hour from the oven or reheated.  Biscuits are a bit of a diva when it comes to humidity, so the longer it sits around the less flaky they will be.

I learned to make traditional biscuits from a woman who said “handle them like you are holding hot coals.”  (It was a KFC shoot and we must have made 1000 biscuits).  It was good advice – don’t touch them much at all. Biscuits are made by cutting little tiny bits of ice cold butter into the dry ingredients, so that each pea-sized bit is flour-coated.  Then you gently add the liquid – buttermilk, perhaps – until it just holds together. If you hot-handle the dough, the butter will start to melt.  The butter should melt only once – in your honking hot 425oF oven – because that creates steam and that, my friends, provides lift. Voilà! Flaky!!

The other reason to lightly handle the dough is to avoid overworking the glutens which will make a tough and sometimes shrunken biscuit. (That joke just wrote itself. I don’t even have to put it in words.)  I got you covered here, this dough is NOT fussy and is made in the processor and uses a small amount of boiling water to pull the dough together.  It’s a bit of the opposite of everything I have just said – no hot coals.  This makes it super simple and you can get away with it in part because it is going atop hot fruit which will also create some steam.

Summer Fruit Pot Pie

Nectarines and Blueberries

Fruit Filling

  • 8 cups pitted and sliced nectarines, about 8 pieces or 4 pounds
  • Juice of one lemon, about 3 Tablespoons (please zest it first and save the zest for the biscuit)
  • 1/2 cup sugar
  • 3 Tablespoons corn starch
  • 1/2 cup cold water
  • 2 cups blueberries

Biscuit Topping:

  • 2 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 2 teaspoons baking powder
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • Zest of one lemon
  • 6 ounces ice-cold butter, cut into bits
  • ¼ cup + 2-3 Tablespoons boiling water

Preheat oven to 425oF. Butter a 9x13x2-inch 3-quart casserole.

Start the Fruit: Combine the nectarines with the lemon juice and sugar.  Set aside.  Dissolve the cornstarch in the cold water and set aside for 5 minutes.

Start the Biscuits: Combine flour, sugar, baking powder, salt, and lemon zest in the work bowl of a food processor.  Pulse to combine.  Cut in the butter with the food processor, by pulsing 8-10 times, until the mixture resembles coarse meal.  (You can also use a pastry cutter).

Back to the Fruit: Combine the nectarines with the cornstarch in a saucepan.  Bring the cornstarch-nectarine mixture to a boil, and cook for 1 minute.  Remove from heat and gently fold in the blueberries.  Transfer fruit mixture to the casserole.

Biscuit Dough

Finish the biscuits: Slowly pour in ¼ cup boiling water and pulse a couple times until just combined. Scrape down sides.  Add additional water one Tablespoon at a time, up to 3 additional Tablespoons.  Pulse with each addition until dough just comes together and becomes spoon-able.  It should remain a bit stiff and not turn gooey. If you add the water all at once, you run the risk of adding too much liquid and melting the butter.  Add it gradually and it will just slightly soften it.  Drop the dough by scant 1/4 cups onto the fruit to form 12 biscuits.  Use a spoon or small spatula to ease the dough out of the cup.  All that butter will let it slide out quite easily.

Biscuits atop Summer Fruit

Bake in bottom third of preheated, foil-lined oven for 35 – 40 minutes until fruit is set, biscuits are golden, and a toothpick inserted in a biscuit comes out clean.  If the biscuits are getting too brown, cover loosely with foil for the last 10 minutes or so. Transfer to a wire rack to cool slightly.  Cool for about an hour, to let the juices set.  Serve while still warm or reheat if it has cooled. Top with ice cream, whipped cream, or plain Greek yogurt.

Serves 12 grateful guests.

Nectarine and Blueberry Pot Pie

Still got peaches or nectarines a plenty? Don’t forget our old friend – roasted beet and peach/nectarine salad!

Roasted Beet and Nectarine Salad

© Copyright: 2016. All rights reserved.

Hey, we want to hear from you!

Don’t forget to Comment, Share & Subscribe to our blog.


  1. Neener says:

    Can’t wait to get bakin’!

  2. Lisa Herman says:

    Making this for sure! Got peaches, nectarines and blueberries. Life is sweet.

    • Katy Keck says:

      Yum!! Report back or post on social media and tag @katykeck!

      • Lisa Herman says:

        So delicious! Made it with these modifications:
        – Half the size (didn’t have as much fruit as I thought)
        – Really didn’t have as many blueberries as I thought, so added a few black grapes. Made it pretty purple, but tasted great
        – Didn’t have any lemons to zest (for shame – used bottled lemon juice!) so I zested an orange – different flavor but ?
        – Forgot about the whole scant 1/4 cup thing, (it was late!) and just plopped the biscuit dough on with a spoon. So not as pretty as yours, but, really, if I make it, it shouldn’t be as pretty as yours

        • Katy Keck says:

          The only reason I say scant was that I was shooting for 12 biscuits, and of course if you vary the biscuit size it will impact cooking time. Sounds like great tweaks and subs that you made. #nojudgement on the bottled lemon juice – I use a bottle of the frozen minute maid lemon juice from time to time. But not the squeezy lemons- ewwww!

  3. Cynthia Lacey Gault says:

    Sadly, no peaches and blueberries here except the frozen variety. I wish I had seen this recipe a few weeks ago when we were stateside. Will save it for another day. Thanks!

    • Katy Keck says:

      While I always use fresh when in season, no shame in frozen. They are generally picked at the peak and quick frozen so they are handled better than we can freeze them ourselves and are of consistently good quality. Not sure about the frozen food in Costa Rica but if you are jonesing for Midwestern American summer dessert, give it a whirl.

      So interesting that this came in my feed today – though apparently published a few days ago – Haven’t compared technique but the concept and ingredients (except I don’t have hazelnut flour and maybe wish I did) are the same. Serendipitous! Been making this for 20 years and working on this post off and on since July 4th.

  4. Emily says:

    Great recipe Katy! I”ll have to give it a try :0)

  5. Cozy Swickard says:

    Okay, you’ve got to stop this. First I was salivating at the panzanella salad, now the fruit pot pie. We can’t go on like this. I’m kidding, fabulous recipes! And just when I didn’t know what o what to do with this last load of peaches. Thank you Katy!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *